The classic Tunnels & Trolls, from the 5th edition to the 7th, is one of the most perfect games ever written. It is a simple game at heart, not really far from the paperback version that I loved in the 1990s, and that my brother and I actually played for a 10-year campaign. The game can support epic campaigns, and it completely feels like sword and sorcery to me, more so than many other games that deliver war and card game mechanics but miss the mark on swinging a big sword and rolling a handful of dice. Tunnels and Trolls really gets across that epic hero feeling just in the clatter of 30 dice for your attack.

This is one of the first role-playing games ever written in the history of the hobby, and it has endured just in its simplicity and elegance. The game just has three classes: the archetypal rogue, warrior, and wizard. It doesn't need anything else; it doesn't need to be piled on with extraneous, superfluous options and false choices. It doesn't need clerics, rangers, druids, or bards. You can play a half-giant or play a fairy; all that you do is modify your ability scores for the race you pick, and you're good to go.
You can start with a strength of 50, and the game is not broken as a result. This is one of those games that captures the feeling of scaling in most Japanese RPGs. Your stats can scale beyond 100, and the game does not break or blink an eye. You just are that strong, that smart, and that good. You scale well beyond the confines of a normal human into superhuman territory, and you can do superhero things easily. The Saving Roll mechanic is universal, works cleanly, and predates D&D's clunkier DR system by decades.
Does the game handle everything with realistic, pedantic detail? Is the game a gritty and detailed fantasy simulation? No, it is not. If you think about classic JRPGs like Dragon Warrior or the original Final Fantasy on the 8-bit Nintendo Entertainment System, Tunnels and Trolls does that type of game well. This is a game where you will scale your ability scores into the hundreds and take on even greater enemies in the next town with ease. Your ability scores can change dramatically: you can gain +10 STR by drinking from a magic pool, or permanently lose 5 IQ points from a curse. Your ability scores can and will change during the adventures, and it is almost guaranteed. Again, that's nothing to fear. It's a feature of the game. Most people can't handle this sort of permanent change, but when you look at the broader picture, where you're using experience points to raise your ability scores anyway, and the next dungeon could always reverse that loss and increase something else, you learn not to worry about your precious ability scores that much.

I still have my 5th Edition paperback book and my 7th Edition hardcover. They still sell the PDFs of these on DriveThru, and I hope they stay available and return to print someday (crowdfunding with leather covers, please). Since this game started as a paperback book, that paperback feel and smell capture the feeling of the hero playing a character in a classic fantasy paperback. Of any game I have played, T&T characters feel like they jump from the pages of classic Tor or Del Rey fantasy paperbacks.
Your character is defined entirely by numbers, a short gear list, and a list of spells if you have them. There are no builds, no subclass abilities, no feats, and no special action types. The game doesn't need them, and these "pure numbers" define the pulp-fantasy paperback characters far better than a modern game or simulation system ever could.
Why? Well, paperback book fantasy heroes don't worry about subclasses, feats, builds, or all this detailed minutia that modern game designers lean into overdesigning, Eurogame pool mechanics, extraneous toys (initiative cards, fate tokens, mana trackers, narrative pools, or real-time timers), and keeps the classic pulp, newsprint paperback, my DEX is 40, the thief walks across the tightrope with ease "jumps from the page" feeling of action that pops and does not need structured rules design showing you how fantasy reality "really works." No, a DEX of 60 is superhuman, and your character does superhuman things; no feats needed, and that D&D 5E rogue stuck with a DEX of 18 (capped at 20) fell off the rope 50 feet ago, and could never hope to achieve epic and mythic levels of ability.

Saving Rolls run the game outside of combat. You set a level, such as a 5th-level IQ SR; you calculate the target number (Level x 5) + 15 (so ours is 40), then subtract your ability score. So if our IQ is 32, our target number is 40 - 32 = 8 or higher on a 2d6. Doubles add and roll again. Monsters are equally easy to handle, with a Monster Rating that determines the dice pool, and special abilities can be linked to spell damage.
Why did this sit in the garage? Well, I have D&D 5E; why do I need another game? I sort of lost interest and drifted away, with rules-like games like FATE or Shadowdark taking T&T's spot on the shelf. I forgot, got distracted by the rules, surrendered to modern designer hubris, and let a game's rules define "what is fantasy" in my head. Going back to the classic pulp fantasy paperbacks, no, D&D 5E can't describe what is going on here. Dungeon Crawl Classics, while directly based on these paperback experiences, still doesn't capture the same feeling and needs far too many tables and charts, class mechanics, and other rulesy tricks to do so. I love DCC, but T&T does fantasy pulp adventures "pulled from the pages" so much better with a handful of dice and beer and pretzels on the side.
So, I forgot, but since games close to my heart never get forgotten and die, the game instantly brings back memories when I pick it up and flip through the pages. I am much closer to this game than many others on the shelf, since my brother and I loved this system, and it took up a lot of our time in the 1990s, away from games like AD&D 2nd Edition and many others. T&T is the game of the ink and wood-pulp smell of the paperback adventure novel.
While T&T has moved on to a new company with a new rules system, nothing beats the classic in my heart. I wish Rebellion well with the new system, and I hope they capture the imaginations of new players. Ken St. Andre, before he passed, made a spiritual successor (with similar rules) in Monsters! Monsters! (and Humans! Humans!), but 7th Edition still remains a high-water mark and ultimate edition of the T&T rules. I love the new games, too, honestly. They are just as chaotic and pulp-fantasy as the classic, and keep the dream alive.
While Ken St. Andre has passed from the mortal realm, his game shall live forever in the pages of adventure fantasy. Highest recommendation.