Saturday, May 18, 2024

ToV PDF Thoughts, Part 10

Part of me is sad that 5E is being seen as only D&D.

It's frustrating to see so many fans who have moved on, and the subsequent backlash from them as Wizards updates every campaign setting. People are angry and make statements like...

They are ruining it. Thus, all of 5E is garbage.

It is a sad reflection of the culture, and many 5E versions don't need to be unfairly portrayed in this light. Tales of the Valiant is doing its own thing. Is ToV progressive? Slightly, but it is not overtly political and in your face. It is primarily presented as middle-of-the-road and viewpoint-neutral. Once you put politics in a game, it takes away from the immersion I crave and pay good money for. I want to be taken away from this world and see a new one through gaming.

Playing a game is like putting on a VR headset and being taken to another world. Remind me of this one, and I realize I am still wearing a VR headset and in one I want to forget.

I meant this when I asked, "Have all the best players left 5E?"

In a way, they have walked away and won't even consider an alternate version of the game.

To many, D&D is Star Wars, and both have been ruined. Pick a reason, Wall Street greed, politics, ruining settings, carelessness about stereotypes, AI art, firing people, the dumb things they say weekly, changing things that don't need to be changed - the reasons to walk away from D&D cut across every political line.

They've pissed off everybody.

People are also sick of 5E. We are 10 years down that road, and people want something new. Once you have "done it all" in a system, it gets to be like the MCU; all the best stories are told, we just see variations of things we have already seen, and the audience hungers for something new—things they have not seen before.

Some are so bought into D&D Beyond that they can't walk away. Nor should they. If someone is having fun there, why should I tell anyone to stop? But the anger around everything is way too high. People now feel they have to defend it.

Me? I feel bad for all the creators that a Wall Street company tried to silence. I was deep in the OSR and watched the fear, anger, and hurt up close. Everyone there is walking away. Pathfinder 2 walked away with the remaster. Troll Lord is walking away with their de-OGL-ification efforts. ACKS2 is free from the OGL. EN World rebuilt their licensing, and they have an SRD-free version. Tales of the Valiant is ORC-licensed.

Everyone is still walking away.

Yet many remain.

People have broken ranks. Other communities outside Wizards are strong. People see their game as their identity and beliefs. That force is much stronger than anything keeping people in D&D. If you feel the people writing the game hate you or mock what you grew up with, you won't play their game.

Even something as dumb as changing a miniature of an iconic painting is enough to confirm people's beliefs that "they hate us." Every mistake, intentional or not, no matter how silly or small, is bias confirmation on both sides. They hate us. Like it or not, we are here.

I read things where people won't even give a Wizards-free version of 5E a chance. Granted, they have bought into new games and chose never to return. I had all 5E in my sell boxes in the garage; I was there and know how they felt. Even the Kobold Press and Level Up books were in there; if I got rid of most of them, I could live without them all.

The sooner I could get rid of those books, the sooner I could bring positivity back into my life.

5E felt like negativity and hate. Even the books I liked reminded me of the time, and it felt like COVID days returning with all the hate, uncertainty, and fear.

The chapter needed to end, and the book needed to be closed.

We all needed to move on.

But Tales of the Valiant came, the PDFs dropped, and I saw a glimmer of hope: that we could have a world where the game brought people together without those feelings of negativity. We could have better things and not throw it all away.

I had lost hope in them.

But I had found it again.

I wonder if this will last or if it is a false hope. I really don't know. Even if Tales of the Valiant fails, I have Level Up Advanced 5E and still like that game. I would be happy if I sold off the 5E books that dragged my collection down and stuck to what works best with that game.

But I will give Kobold Press a chance like I gave Pathfinder 2 a chance. It didn't work out with Paizo, and I feel bad that game wasn't for me. But Kobold Press deserves the same opportunity.

Things will be different this time.

But, at least, I have hope.

I dream of a world where we can all play together again.

Friday, May 17, 2024

ToV PDF Thoughts, Part 9

One of the biggest hurdles Tales of the Valiant has is apathy. Many of the people pissed off by the OGL scandal have moved on to other games, joined those communities, and already walked out the door. They are done with 5E, and even with clone versions of it. Different communities have arisen, and people are over there, having fun and bonding around other games.

Fracturing the market was one of the most significant outcomes of the OGL scandal.

People walked out the door, and I doubt you can get them to return to a game they played for 10 years and gave up on. The 5E market is still huge, but you want to target influencers and heavy users. One influencer or blog writer's reach is thousands of players, and every voice counts.

I had all my 5E books in sell boxes, ready to go out the door. I wasn't coming back. Sadly, even Level Up was getting sold. I saw support elsewhere; games like C&C are hot and I followed along. Why did I come back? Giving Tales of the Valiant a chance is the right and fair thing to do. Once I saw the PDFs and the app support, I knew I needed to cover them.

This is a big deal. This is an attempt to dethrone the king.

Granted, that is not an easy task. Many players are so bought into D&D Beyond it is like getting someone with a few thousand dollars of app store purchases on an iPhone to switch to Android. Also, people's "game choice" is becoming politicized, and I get the feeling that people who try to get people to switch games or even look at alternatives get attacked for "shrinking the market and player base."

It is all idiotic and stupid out there today.

Back in my day, we played a dozen different RPGs with different rules and loved them all. The variety and choice were good since we would not get bored with one game. These days, asking someone to switch rules is like trying to get them to accept a new political party and abandon their friends and social circles.

Me? I never bought into or used D&D Beyond. I didn't use it and wasn't interested in it. Why would I go to a wine tasting if I don't drink wine? Like Pathfinder 2, it wasn't for me.

But I did play Open 5E games like Level Up Advanced 5E. I originally bought the LU monster book for Low Fantasy Gaming (by mistake), which got me started in Open 5E, but I realized the monster book was entirely for another version of 5E. I looked into LU and enjoyed that game since it seriously attempted to incorporate old-school and 4E mechanics into the design.

Level Up and LFG were my introductions to Open 5E, and I still like them.

And then we had Wizards' OGL blunder, and so many DMs and heavy users walked away. People who knew what this was about cared deeply, and they walked in solidarity with a community of creators and players who were gravely hurt by the decision. The echoes of that decision and the pain it caused are still happening today as everyone abandons the flawed OGL license and rewrites their games.

Level Up rewrote the SRD to exclude licensed language; they are immune. They did that long before this happened, which is some fantastic foresight and effort on their part. People laughed at them for doing this "waste of time" early on, and they were right.

I still ask myself, how did they know?

Level Up's story is still amazing, and the entire game (not just select pieces) is now being published under an SRD. And unlike the 5.1 SRD, this is complete, with no removed content, AFAIK, so it can be played as-is, and you can enjoy a complete game. They are selling through their OGL-licensed books (they just used them for convenience) and planning for a non-OGL version (with their starter set coming soon). The A5E SRD is published using ORC, CC, and legacy-OGL licenses, so using it is easy.

Level Up is more community-focused, so the pillars of play (combat, exploration, social) are part of the game's core design. Favorites from 4E appear (eladrin, dragonborn, a warlord-like class). Level Up sometimes feels like a marriage between 4E and  AD&D, with 5E rules, and it is a fantastic experience.

Level Up feels like 4E continued, and it is a game I would consider using the Nerrath campaign setting with. Hardcore 4E players will know what this means since we all loved that sandbox setting, and D&D 5E never did it justice. Level Up goes way beyond 4E, and once you buy in, the options and choices for characters and classes become mind-blowing.

Tales is a different game, like a streamlined 5E with a CR+1 challenge level. This is the Pathfinder 1e model, compared with 3.5E, and Tales also has that "power up" feeling that 4E had - but none of the cool stuff. Tales is doing its own thing and starting new, with a more Midgard-focused feel. The base rules are generic and free of a setting, but the look and feel are Midgard.

Tales will go in their own direction, which is great since the hobby needs new ideas and blood. The digital tools are excellent and make the barrier to entry very low, I can have a character in a few minutes and be ready to play.

Both games are worthy of taking the crown.

All they need are voices of support.

Thursday, May 16, 2024

ToV PDF Thoughts, Part 8

I am playing both Tales of the Valiant and Level Up Advanced 5E. I like both games very much. I know; I had these in my sell boxes, and I still have two boxes of 5E stuff that are just junk and going out the door, so all I have left is the best.

You must eliminate "junk books" from your collection; they will drag down everything.

My journey with 5E has been unique. I started with the first three Wizards books, and then, for various reasons, I decided to skip the rest. However, I have the three-book gift set with Tasha's, although I haven't delved into it yet. That set is getting sold. This sense of freedom to explore other game versions, unencumbered by the weight of 5E, is what drives me. For me, 5E was never about anything beyond the first books and the SRD.

My mind has yet to be poisoned into thinking that parts of the game introduced after the first core books are irreplaceable. They never were a part of my experience with 5E. You get people who have been on D&D Beyond for 5 years, and the game is what is on that site and nothing else.

I love third-party 5E books, but the word "love" is tainted by how awful many of them are in terms of balance. Many of them have great ideas but terribly flawed execution. Love is as far as I will use them, with some being inspirational only and a mess to use in a serious game where balance is essential.

How many people play 5E by the rules and keep an eye on balance? From many discussions I read online, I don't get a strong feeling most care about balance.

So, I am splitting my library in half. One shelf will have mostly Kobold Press books and all my Tales of the Valiant rulebooks. This will be the "core 5E game" going forward. I like this since Hero Lab supports it well. When released, the expansion books will be added, making an excellent "core game," much like my old Pathfinder 1e collection. Core books, expansions, and a world are ready to go. Tales plus Midgard is a powerful combination, and this is the Pathfinder plus Golarion combo that made that game so compelling.

If you want a drop-in, replace D&D, primary system plus world like Pathfinder 1e players had back in the days of 4E, ToV plus Midgard is your thing. The balance is more on 2024-level numbers since the power creep of the last 10 years is factored in and the game rebalanced.

The only weakness is that it is very early, and only the first rulebook is in the system. There are few character options beyond the basics, but we are early, and everyone is learning. I hope the Kobold Press option, magic, and monster books get added soon to the ToV Hero Lab store.

I am helping out by filing bugs and using the character-building app.

The second shelf will be for Level Up Advanced 5E, based around the Lost Lands setting. Level Up is an excellent old-school-inspired version of 5E, and since I need to do the character sheets by hand, any books that do not support the online character creation tools for ToV will go here. Also, if a monster book is more of a CR+0-based (2014 balance) book, it will work better with Level Up than Tales.

Level Up is more of an old-school legacy 2014-balanced 5E support. I wish I could get a decent character designer for this, but it won't happen. It doesn't matter in the end since if this is where I do things by hand, I am free to use any option in any book.

I like Level Up's old-school design sensibilities and support for the pillars of play. We may need to wait until September and the ToV GM's Guide to see more campaign options, and this may change. Level Up also tightens up math and numeric balance.

Wednesday, May 15, 2024

2024 PHB Cover

https://www.gameinformer.com/2024/05/14/the-art-of-the-new-dungeons-dragons

The new cover of the 2024 PHB sucks. People are nitpicking about this or that, and most of it is silly.

Why don't I like it?

The "big bad" of the scene, the red dragon, is shoved all the way, half off the bottom, and covered up by the text. Two kobolds, the only other threat, and half cut off the side of the page. There is no threat. There is no danger. It is all pushed off the page and covered up by text.

A giant gold dragon head—a good dragon—hovers over them, more prominent than anything else on the page. The cover has the message, "Game is easy, GMNPC gold dragon will protect you, nothing can hurt you."

What were they thinking?

There is no threat, flow, or focus, and the composition of things on the page as a book cover is horrendous. As interior art, this is great. As a cover, it fails horribly.

Good Video: Tales of the Valiant First Look & Review

Here is an excellent video on the differences between ToV and 5E. This is worth checking out, please toss the creator a favorite, watch, and subscribe!

ToV PDF Thoughts, Part 7

It's intriguing to ponder if D&D's unique blend of story-gaming influences, particularly evident in its 5E iteration, contributes to its charm. Undoubtedly, this aspect of the game has played a significant role in its widespread appeal. However, the 'story game mechanics' integrated into the game could benefit further refinement. With its perceived immunity to death and consequences, the current implementation has led some to draw comparisons to games like FATE.

You tell a story, something-something rules come up, roll a die, nobody dies, keep the story going, something rules, please roll, and so on. People get "knocked unconscious" constantly. Death really isn't death.

Even role protection things like a rogue's "find traps" have been given al-a-carte to casters. Everyone has dark vision, so light has been minimalized compared to storytelling. Passive skills turn the DM into a Blu-ray player; reading the next paragraph. The SRD version of Find Traps is vague enough that it could be a trap detector.

Shadowdark, on the other hand, holds these aspects to a higher standard, which is why it resonates with many players. Light is a finite resource, just like your life. The game asks: Do you risk another room for profit or cut and run while still ahead?

In Shadowark it is not just character backstory. The dungeon is not just a backdrop; it's a crucial element of the game. The dungeon is the story.

This is where Tales of the Valiant comes in. A mechanically similar 5E implementation, rebalanced for a CR+1 encounter level, solves many problems but maintains others for compatibility. The death mechanics are just as soft, and I would need to patch these to have the game I want.

Why patch? I will lose interest (again) in 5E and go to games with better rules. That Shadowdark-level challenge needs to be there. Things need to be tough. Decisions need to be made. ToV does make many positive changes, like getting rid of the 'Find Traps' spell and streamlining the rules. They move rituals into their own spell category, like 4E. They fix the level 2 subclass problem.

But Tales of the Valiant doesn't invalidate games like Level Up Advanced 5E. The community projects to rebuild 5E into a better game are not new. LUA5E is a CR+0 implementation of 5E with a stringent clean-up of all math and integrates old-school concepts and pillars of play. Rangers excel at the exploration game. Social classes have meaning. Death is softer than Shadowdark, but each time you are knocked down and avoid dying, it begins ticking up exhaustion.

Where Tales of the Valiant is a cleaned-up, streamlined heroic version of 5E, Level Up is a tighter, more detailed, meatier character, pillars of play, in-depth, and old-school implementation of 5E. The math in LUA5E is tight; every nut and bolt has been tightened up and checked, and the team rewrote the entire game (no SRD content) to make a clean-rule implementation of the game.

The character options in Level Up are fantastic, and with all the expansions, there are so many choices that they will make your head spin. You can be a velociraptor-riding Sherlock Holmes. The only downside is that the game loads up your character with over a dozen special abilities once you make all the required choices. As a result, it is a more "heavyweight" game, but it supports all three pillars of play nicely and even has a resource-tracking and resting game for survival-focused adventures that make a few classes must-haves in a balanced party.

Even Level Up fixes the Find Traps spell, too, but it makes it a "Are there traps in the line-of-sight and spell radius" detection power rather than a magic trap finder. It won't tell you how many and where they are; you still need a rogue. Also, Level Up has the concept of "rare spells" as unique finds, giving casters extra depth and motivation.

Where ToV captures that easy-to-play and streamlined 5E experience I was looking for, Level Up goes in-depth and supports classic old-school pillars of play. Both of them have fantastic community fixes and improvements.

Is there room for both?

I say yes. Since ToV is CR+1 that is a more action-heavy and heroic version of the game. Level Up is a CR+0 "pillars of play" style where things are toned down, more on the familiar balance level, with complex and detailed characters, much like the classic Aftermath game. With Level Up, you want more to your characters and get more. With Tales, you want fast-playing and higher-powered action, which you get.

I have a few classic dungeons converted over to play with the 5E rules. While I could play them with Tales, they would work better with a CR+0 system and one that supports old-school concepts like the "pillars of play." So Level Up is a fine choice here, and it gives the rules support I want for an old-school flavored game.

This may change once the ToV GM's Guide introduces optional rules and a hardcore mode and supports exploration games like Level Up, but that is a wait-and-see. Right now, Level Up does the best job at a CR+0.

Tales will do the best Kobold Press adventures, so if you are playing those, ToV is the best choice.

Tuesday, May 14, 2024

ToV PDF Thoughts, Part 6

https://koboldpress.com/kpstore/product/tales-of-the-valiant-conversion-guide-pdf/

Kobold Press released a conversion guide that lists the differences between ToV and 5E. 

One intriguing aspect is how rituals are handled in Level Up A5E and the SRD. Here, a ritual is a tag applied to a spell, and it's fascinating to see how this differs from ToV. In the SRD and D&D, some ritual spells can be cast as usual or as a ritual.

In ToV, spellcasting classes have some rituals that can be prepared daily. Dual-use rituals and regular spells have been eliminated. Rituals can be learned freely, but only a certain number can be prepared.

It's a positive shift that brings ToV closer to D&D 4E. This change suggests that some spells should only be a ritual, like Raise Dead in the SRD (and Level Up). In these systems, it's a normal spell that consumes a 5th-level spell slot, takes an hour to cast, and lacks a ritual tag. This means the 5th-level spell slot is used up after casting, which could be seen as a limitation.

Why shouldn't this just be a ritual? It isn't a combat spell, so why not? If my character knows Raise Dead, they could raise dead all day, once per hour, provided the diamonds hold out. Rituals are spells casters collect and "slot in" if they think they will need one today.

Plus, why confuse the spell system and overcomplicate it with the old "some spells are rituals, some are both" and so on? Some spells are rituals and go in a list, and are tracked via a "number of rituals known" number. All the other spells are expected. Like the "cantrip split" with a particular category of spells, it streamlines spellcasting nicely.