I ran out of shelf space.
So Tales of the Valiant is half upstairs and half downstairs, and sitting in tight storage boxes. Part of me feels the game can be saved by cutting the library down to its core, which means cutting out 90% of my 50-book library and the system bloat I've collected over the years. This is gonna be a tough project if I take it on and reduce my core books to just the best ones. It will be tough to choose and go through this process, which is why I am more on the side of putting it all away instead of sorting through 8 boxes of books.
There is a core game worth saving, and it doesn't include any of the setting material I've collected. While I love settings like Midgard, the weight of the books and adventures that I've collected is just too much for me to support. This even extends to things like extra spells in monster books that clutter the core system; the game is at a point where it's too big for me to play, and I have 2 choices. One is to put it all away and not deal with it because I have enough games to play without 5E sitting around. The other choice is to sort through it and create a very small library of playable core books that support the minimum system.
The issue is, once I keep 5E out, it invites other books in, and the process begins again. It also invites revisiting the crates I do put in the garage, which will eventually end up there to pull books out of, and I'll go through all this again and again. I have to ask myself the question: whether supporting a simpler game with fewer books, like Dragonbane or Shadowdark, is the better choice for me long-term.
The problem with 5E is that the system is just way too massive. For one person to support. The only way this game survives in my current space is if I dramatically cut it down to just the core books and limit the options so much that it sits on a shelf next to smaller games and offers more than they do. That is one of the questions: can 5E support a campaign, as well as smaller games, if the number of books is cut down to a minimum?
A game like Dragonbane, OSE, OSRIC, or Shadowdark can support a full campaign with a minimal set of books. I am so used to 5e being so bloated that it is hard to cut that system down to core books and have it deliver the experience that smaller games give me with fewer rules. There is something about the design of 5e that invites so much bloat that it feels maddening at times. The combination of it being a class and subclass system, when a skill-based game does essentially the same thing, plus more, invites piles of useless options to be introduced into the game. In a game like GURPS, adding one or 2 skills and an advantage to a character build essentially accomplishes the role of an entire subclass and a few dozen pages of rules in 5E, and it doesn't lock me out of other choices.
That is one of the core issues with 5E: the game is so much like a video game that they will design character options that are unnecessary. These character options often lock you out of other character options, and all of a sudden, the more subclasses you have, the less choice you have, and the less your character can do without stepping on another subclass. When there are only three subclasses in the entire game, you can assume each subclass does so much more. When there are 10 subclasses to Fighter, each gets very specialized, and due to role protection, you start to need to limit what other subclasses can do in order to protect one or 2 choices that, in all likelihood, will never get taken.
I have better, easier, faster games already out on my shelves, and adding a stripped-down Tales of the Valiant is a questionable decision, but also a question I want to answer. I don't want to pull in eight or 12 crates of 5E books back into the house because it is too much for me to support. There is an overall feeling that I just need to play smaller games these days, and I shouldn't bother with something that big or something that can expand infinitely. The game will get so big again that I'll never touch it, because when faced with a wall of books, I just give up and play a video game.
This is something I'm gonna be thinking about this winter.
Can a version of 5E be cut down and saved?
Or is what I have with other games more than enough for me?
No comments:
Post a Comment