Friday, November 20, 2026

Off the Shelf: Mercenaries, Spies & Private Eyes

Next to my T&T 7th Edition hardcover is this gem, the hardcover for Mercenaries, Spies & Private Eyes.

This is one of the best surviving secret-agent and modern-era adventure fiction games from the 1980s. It has a classiness and style all its own. The game feels like it could play any 007 novel as an adventure, or any classic Cold War espionage story, or even the action-packed Mack Bolan or Able Team men’s adventure novels. The same rules support everything from Sherlock Holmes in the 1880s and pulp adventurers and gangsters in the 1930s to the modern day (in the game’s days, the 1990s). The book even includes stats for Sherlock Holmes and his companions, so it is instantly playable as an 1880s detective game. MSPE also holds the crime dramas of the 1960s and 70s, Dirty Harry or Death Wish, Columbo, Magnum P.I., Kojak, and the older hardboiled work of Sam Spade and Raymond Chandler.

It uses the T&T rules, but a very toned-down version with lower stats. That is fine with me. The numbers stay human-scale instead of climbing into the dozens and hundreds, and the game still feels and plays like a mature treatment of the source material: tense, roaming, world-traveling, and action-packed.

Like T&T, the game feels like the paperback novels jumping off the page and coming to life. It is not over-designed or flashy, and that fits the source material like a fine tailored suit. A classy mercenary could waltz through a palace in a tuxedo one day, meeting a deposed noble, then the next day go to war with a small force in combat fatigues, a 9mm Uzi slung over his shoulder, to rescue his kidnapped daughter from rebels holding her on a remote island for a fortune.

Also, since the game has its roots in Tunnels and Trolls, monsters from that system can be easily used, and it's trivial to create anything you may need, from shoggoths to werewolves - pick an MR and a few special abilities, and you are done. Most will be incredibly strong due to scaling, but once you know what the characters can collectively dish out, finding MR ratings that work is pretty straightforward, and modern weapons always even the score. Also, modern weapons will shave a ton of MR off a monster quickly on a hit, given armor, and the first few of the monster's blows may kill a few investigators; the rest may have a chance.

And T&T and MSPE combat requires theater of the mind and applying spite damage in interesting ways, so the battles don't have to be "just the dice." Be creative, measure the damage, figure out the blows, and be descriptive! Ask for Saving Rolls to avoid special effects. Describe overkill with bone-crushing and blood-curdling detail. Like a novel, the "writer" needs to flex their stuff and bring the details to life.

Though, to be honest, adjusting the MR of a T&T monster or encounter is far easier than adjusting a stat block for a 5E monster or building an encounter in that game. Once you have the basics of T&T and how MR works down, balancing an encounter in either T&T or MSPE is a lot easier than in 5E.

Also, the gun stats are trivially easy to convert, so a modern-day game is also a trivial conversion and upgrade. There is an impression of “old game, old stats,” and it isn’t true. This system is just as capable and easy to use from 1880 to 2026, or any other era of play.

Many games in the genre get overdesigned and flashy, with tons of character options. The 3.5E treatment of Spycraft stacked feats, classes, and powers onto archetypes pulled from action movies. MSPE does not need that level of design or hundreds of pages of rules support for class builds. You are skilled professionals with special knowledge and experience, and those skills come into play in a time and place that feels real, yet still invites action and grand storytelling.

A true classic, it holds up even today due to its literary roots and bookish treatment of the source material. Because the game stays true to the books and novels, it endures far longer than many games based on movies or current-day stories. That is why it still holds up.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Off the Shelf: Tunnels and Trolls (7th Edition)

The classic Tunnels & Trolls, from the 5th edition to the 7th, is one of the most perfect games ever written. It is a simple game at heart, not really far from the paperback version that I loved in the 1990s, and that my brother and I actually played for a 10-year campaign. The game can support epic campaigns, and it completely feels like sword and sorcery to me, more so than many other games that deliver war and card game mechanics but miss the mark on swinging a big sword and rolling a handful of dice. Tunnels and Trolls really gets across that epic hero feeling just in the clatter of 30 dice for your attack.

This is one of the first role-playing games ever written in the history of the hobby, and it has endured just in its simplicity and elegance. The game just has three classes: the archetypal rogue, warrior, and wizard. It doesn't need anything else; it doesn't need to be piled on with extraneous, superfluous options and false choices. It doesn't need clerics, rangers, druids, or bards. You can play a half-giant or play a fairy; all that you do is modify your ability scores for the race you pick, and you're good to go.

You can start with a strength of 50, and the game is not broken as a result. This is one of those games that captures the feeling of scaling in most Japanese RPGs. Your stats can scale beyond 100, and the game does not break or blink an eye. You just are that strong, that smart, and that good. You scale well beyond the confines of a normal human into superhuman territory, and you can do superhero things easily. The Saving Roll mechanic is universal, works cleanly, and predates D&D's clunkier DR system by decades.

Does the game handle everything with realistic, pedantic detail? Is the game a gritty and detailed fantasy simulation? No, it is not. If you think about classic JRPGs like Dragon Warrior or the original Final Fantasy on the 8-bit Nintendo Entertainment System, Tunnels and Trolls does that type of game well. This is a game where you will scale your ability scores into the hundreds and take on even greater enemies in the next town with ease. Your ability scores can change dramatically: you can gain +10 STR by drinking from a magic pool, or permanently lose 5 IQ points from a curse. Your ability scores can and will change during the adventures, and it is almost guaranteed. Again, that's nothing to fear. It's a feature of the game. Most people can't handle this sort of permanent change, but when you look at the broader picture, where you're using experience points to raise your ability scores anyway, and the next dungeon could always reverse that loss and increase something else, you learn not to worry about your precious ability scores that much.

I still have my 5th Edition paperback book and my 7th Edition hardcover. They still sell the PDFs of these on DriveThru, and I hope they stay available and return to print someday (crowdfunding with leather covers, please). Since this game started as a paperback book, that paperback feel and smell capture the feeling of the hero playing a character in a classic fantasy paperback. Of any game I have played, T&T characters feel like they jump from the pages of classic Tor or Del Rey fantasy paperbacks.

Your character is defined entirely by numbers, a short gear list, and a list of spells if you have them. There are no builds, no subclass abilities, no feats, and no special action types. The game doesn't need them, and these "pure numbers" define the pulp-fantasy paperback characters far better than a modern game or simulation system ever could.

Why? Well, paperback book fantasy heroes don't worry about subclasses, feats, builds, or all this detailed minutia that modern game designers lean into overdesigning, Eurogame pool mechanics, extraneous toys (initiative cards, fate tokens, mana trackers, narrative pools, or real-time timers), and keeps the classic pulp, newsprint paperback, my DEX is 40, the thief walks across the tightrope with ease "jumps from the page" feeling of action that pops and does not need structured rules design showing you how fantasy reality "really works." No, a DEX of 60 is superhuman, and your character does superhuman things; no feats needed, and that D&D 5E rogue stuck with a DEX of 18 (capped at 20) fell off the rope 50 feet ago, and could never hope to achieve epic and mythic levels of ability.

Saving Rolls run the game outside of combat. You set a level, such as a 5th-level IQ SR; you calculate the target number (Level x 5) + 15 (so ours is 40), then subtract your ability score. So if our IQ is 32, our target number is 40 - 32 = 8 or higher on a 2d6. Doubles add and roll again. Monsters are equally easy to handle, with a Monster Rating that determines the dice pool, and special abilities can be linked to spell damage.

Why did this sit in the garage? Well, I have D&D 5E; why do I need another game? I sort of lost interest and drifted away, with rules-like games like FATE or Shadowdark taking T&T's spot on the shelf. I forgot, got distracted by the rules, surrendered to modern designer hubris, and let a game's rules define "what is fantasy" in my head. Going back to the classic pulp fantasy paperbacks, no, D&D 5E can't describe what is going on here. Dungeon Crawl Classics, while directly based on these paperback experiences, still doesn't capture the same feeling and needs far too many tables and charts, class mechanics, and other rulesy tricks to do so. I love DCC, but T&T does fantasy pulp adventures "pulled from the pages" so much better with a handful of dice and beer and pretzels on the side.

So, I forgot, but since games close to my heart never get forgotten and die, the game instantly brings back memories when I pick it up and flip through the pages. I am much closer to this game than many others on the shelf, since my brother and I loved this system, and it took up a lot of our time in the 1990s, away from games like AD&D 2nd Edition and many others. T&T is the game of the ink and wood-pulp smell of the paperback adventure novel.

While T&T has moved on to a new company with a new rules system, nothing beats the classic in my heart. I wish Rebellion well with the new system, and I hope they capture the imaginations of new players. Ken St. Andre, before he passed, made a spiritual successor (with similar rules) in Monsters! Monsters! (and Humans! Humans!), but 7th Edition still remains a high-water mark and ultimate edition of the T&T rules. I love the new games, too, honestly. They are just as chaotic and pulp-fantasy as the classic, and keep the dream alive.

While Ken St. Andre has passed from the mortal realm, his game shall live forever in the pages of adventure fantasy. Highest recommendation.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Ken St. Andre, RIP

I loved these games growing up, and so did my brother.

Ken St. Andre passed away, and we lost another founding father of roleplaying.

The games are fun. Either edition of T&T (5 or 7) holds up even today, and his own Monsters! Monsters! game shines brightly and keeps the legacy of the "handful of d6" dungeon system alive.

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/152613/deluxe-tunnels-trolls-2015-edition

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/210996/tunnels-trolls-rules-5th-editon

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/465654/monsters-monsters-2-7-edition

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/493344/humans-humans-1st-edition

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/414074/monsterary-of-zimrala

Saving Tales of the Valiant

I ran out of shelf space.

So Tales of the Valiant is half upstairs and half downstairs, and sitting in tight storage boxes. Part of me feels the game can be saved by cutting the library down to its core, which means cutting out 90% of my 50-book library and the system bloat I've collected over the years. This is gonna be a tough project if I take it on and reduce my core books to just the best ones. It will be tough to choose and go through this process, which is why I am more on the side of putting it all away instead of sorting through 8 boxes of books.

There is a core game worth saving, and it doesn't include any of the setting material I've collected. While I love settings like Midgard, the weight of the books and adventures that I've collected is just too much for me to support. This even extends to things like extra spells in monster books that clutter the core system; the game is at a point where it's too big for me to play, and I have 2 choices. One is to put it all away and not deal with it because I have enough games to play without 5E sitting around. The other choice is to sort through it and create a very small library of playable core books that support the minimum system.

The issue is, once I keep 5E out, it invites other books in, and the process begins again. It also invites revisiting the crates I do put in the garage, which will eventually end up there to pull books out of, and I'll go through all this again and again. I have to ask myself the question: whether supporting a simpler game with fewer books, like Dragonbane or Shadowdark, is the better choice for me long-term.

The problem with 5E is that the system is just way too massive. For one person to support. The only way this game survives in my current space is if I dramatically cut it down to just the core books and limit the options so much that it sits on a shelf next to smaller games and offers more than they do. That is one of the questions: can 5E support a campaign, as well as smaller games, if the number of books is cut down to a minimum?

A game like Dragonbane, OSE, OSRIC, or Shadowdark can support a full campaign with a minimal set of books. I am so used to 5e being so bloated that it is hard to cut that system down to core books and have it deliver the experience that smaller games give me with fewer rules. There is something about the design of 5e that invites so much bloat that it feels maddening at times. The combination of it being a class and subclass system, when a skill-based game does essentially the same thing, plus more, invites piles of useless options to be introduced into the game. In a game like GURPS, adding one or 2 skills and an advantage to a character build essentially accomplishes the role of an entire subclass and a few dozen pages of rules in 5E, and it doesn't lock me out of other choices.

That is one of the core issues with 5E: the game is so much like a video game that they will design character options that are unnecessary. These character options often lock you out of other character options, and all of a sudden, the more subclasses you have, the less choice you have, and the less your character can do without stepping on another subclass. When there are only three subclasses in the entire game, you can assume each subclass does so much more. When there are 10 subclasses to Fighter, each gets very specialized, and due to role protection, you start to need to limit what other subclasses can do in order to protect one or 2 choices that, in all likelihood, will never get taken.

I have better, easier, faster games already out on my shelves, and adding a stripped-down Tales of the Valiant is a questionable decision, but also a question I want to answer. I don't want to pull in eight or 12 crates of 5E books back into the house because it is too much for me to support. There is an overall feeling that I just need to play smaller games these days, and I shouldn't bother with something that big or something that can expand infinitely. The game will get so big again that I'll never touch it, because when faced with a wall of books, I just give up and play a video game.

This is something I'm gonna be thinking about this winter.

Can a version of 5E be cut down and saved?

Or is what I have with other games more than enough for me?

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

But Fantasy

I have not felt this disinterested in the modern fantasy genre in a long time. The hero-first look, real armor not needed, sword on a back scabbard, no helmets, Supercut hairstyles, never-die, carry as much as you want, pure MMO-style fantasy, is flat-out as tired to me as hair metal was at the end of the 1980s. I see a game that leads with that image and that assumption, and it is an instant nope. I may get over this phase, but it is going to take a while, and it is going to take a great game that rekindles the love of this dead-feeling genre.

I nicknamed it “butt fantasy,” the same way people started calling the radio-station rock of the late 90s and 2000s “butt rock.” Those stations would proudly announce they played “nothing but rock,” so the genre picked up the name. Here the justifying phrase is “but this is fantasy!” - the line people reach for when you notice the pauldron that is supposed to count as full plate, the hair that never needs a helmet, the infinite magic, the backpack that holds fifty days of iron rations plus 5,000 gold pieces. Hence the whole modern default genre is now butt fantasy.

And to be completely honest, I love the butt rock genre, so this sarcastic yet endearing nickname may be what eventually saves this one for me.

My brother and I loved D&D 4E, and that was one of the first games that leaned hard into the brash, hero-first, charge-in-and-kick-butt style. We fell in love with it as a miniatures game. It still felt like a choice then. Perhaps Draw Steel is the way back for me. Perhaps I just need one game that does the charge-in version very well and keeps the number of books to a minimum. I don’t know yet. Empty hope on a shelf is worse than admitting I need time away.

D&D and 5E have never felt so overextended and tired. The entire notion of “D&D” feels like it needs a massive reset. 5E especially: the glut and bloat of books is impossible to manage. Even if you pare it down to 5.5E only, the amount of stuff you need to buy and keep straight is terrible, and it only gets worse. Add a few broken subclasses or character races - lineages, heritages, cultures, species, communities, whatever they are calling them this week - and the game gets worse. It got to the point where I had eight shelves of 5E books and the only way out was to put them all in the garage. Pathfinder 1E reached the same place: too big, too much, good game, but I could not play it all. Starfinder 1E got there too. I had subscriptions to Pathfinder 2, and I couldn’t support it all.

My last big-shelf games are GURPS, DCC, and Palladium. The great thing about those is they still have one or two core rulebooks, and the rest is expansion fluff. When a game has multiple core rulebooks, it dies for me. Once you need several volumes just to know what a character can do, the interest collapses before the first session.

So where am I in fantasy?

Two places. GURPS is my default low-fantasy game. I have to track every pound. Helmets matter. Armor protection and location matter a lot. Armor is heavy and slows you down. Weapon skill and choice matter. Actions and movement matter. Turns are one second long, and your action economy is simple: one thing in one second. Butt fantasy and its special initiative trackers, multiple action types, and all the bells and whistles around the question that should be simple—“what can you do in a turn?”—muck up the combat turn so much that it takes some players thirty minutes to figure out their actions. Modern fantasy is overdesigned into some sort of card game with tapping, phases, special actions, and rules borrowed from Euro-games, rather than something meant to simulate pushing a steel blade into someone’s gut.

The dance around action and combat resolution feels like sewing layers of lace, sequins, and fancy adornments onto a Kevlar vest, then calling combat “fixed” and “meaningful.” The goal is death: burning a goblin’s face off, bleeding them out with arrow punctures, mauling them with a pet wolf’s jaws, or hacking them to pieces with axes and swords like a butcher shop. Those fancy butt-fantasy clothes are going to need aprons to catch all the blood, and you will walk out of there smelling like burnt flesh.

Shadowdark is a viable option. For fast play and new players, Shadowdark all the way. But the grit and detail of GURPS give me much more than a simplified 5E ruleset in the same genre.

Fantasy Hero and the Champions system is the other track. It can be just as brutal and unhinged as GURPS, but this game gives me complete control of powers, defenses, and attacks to a level where I am having fun creating my own magic and playing battles out like a fantasy version of Battletech. GURPS can do this too, but I have the Hero books out, and I like using them.

Game designers and their magic systems in the modern fantasy genre think they know better than you, and frankly they don’t know a thing. Multiple heal spells for multiple action types just smack me as overdesigned and unnecessary - more spells to remember: healing word, cure light wounds, and the healing spell of the week. One heal, one action, and we are done. Big heal and small heal. It doesn’t need to get that complicated.

Game designers and overdesigned fantasy games are killing the genre for me. A great low-fantasy game where every choice matters - where not carrying around a backpack with fifty days of iron rations so I can wear a chain vest actually matters - is what I want. Skills matter. Stats matter. Tactics matter. Every hit matters.

My loss of interest in modern fantasy comes from over-designed game-designer hubris. I need some time away and a reason to come back. A game that still treats the hit as the point, and that still fits in one or two books, would be enough. Until then, the radio station can keep playing the same playlist. I’ll be over here with the books that still let a sword be a tool that removes limbs and carves up meat.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Fable: Cosplay Fantasy

I keep seeing this picture, and the same thought hits me every time: these are supposed to be warriors.

No helmets. One shoulder pad and a bracer between them. That’s it. An American football player is wearing more protection than either of these characters. One solid mace blow to the head ends the night. A spear in the gut is a vitals hit. The first decent shot to an arm or a leg, and that limb is done. In GURPS terms, you’re looking at DR 1 on a shoulder and DR 1 on a forearm, everything else at zero. The world still has weapons. The picture just decided they don’t matter.

Then the weapons themselves. Broadsword on the back, the usual movie scabbard you can’t actually draw when something is trying to kill you. Think about the physics of drawing a three-foot broadsword directly forward from over your shoulder. Take a yardstick, hold it over your shoulder, and try to draw it straight forward and up from inside a back scabbard without slicing your neck open or needing a four-foot-long arm.

Watch the demo. The bow shows up when they need it and disappears again: no quiver, no arrows. Instant swaps, like cycling Doom guns. Nothing about how these people carry or use their gear is real. It only has to look right while the combat engine is running.

This is the normal 5.5E cosplay-fantasy package now. Characters are sold as fighters, drawn with costume trim instead of armor and props instead of equipment. The game’s own art already gave up on the world being dangerous. “But it’s fantasy,” people say, and it only works if you’ve checked out of reality and said protection, weight, where gear is carried, and getting hit stopped mattering. Most of the time, the setting still pretends those things count. The character designs just ignore them.

Put the same picture next to any game that still bothers with sectional armor, hit locations, or actual loadouts and it gets ridiculous fast. No helmet. Almost no DR. A sword you can’t draw. A bow that appears from nowhere, and no quiver to pull from. Those aren’t artistic choices at that point. They’re the picture contradicting the rules sitting right next to it. The art checked out of the fiction. The game still has numbers for getting stabbed; the characters were drawn like that part was optional.

And yeah, it rubs off. When the presentation treats armor and weapons like costume pieces, the table treats the threats the same way. Everything turns jokey because the picture already decided none of it was serious, and even massive injury can be slept off. I’m tired of the entire "but fantasy" genre. The cosplay-fantasy trope has been everywhere long enough that it now reads as empty: warriors who can’t survive the first solid hit, gear that only exists for the trailer, and a whole genre that stopped thinking about whether any of this still makes sense inside the world it claims to simulate.

Fantasy needs reality to differentiate itself, to keep things grounded, and to make the fantastic feel magical. If the character designs and the rules can't take the world seriously, how am I supposed to?

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Off the Shelf: Twilight: 2000

The Free League box is back on the coffee table. Core set plus the three expansions. Operation Reset is still pre-ordered. I haven’t opened the encounter cards yet. I’m just looking at it.

I wrote about this set when it arrived in February 2022. That was the day the news out of Ukraine turned real. My brother and I had run a long campaign with the original rules, and opening the new box felt bittersweet. I pulled it off the shelf again in October 2024 and wrote about those nights. The Free League edition is not the same game, but it carries the same frame. You are on your own now. The war was a waste. What you do next is up to you.

Those nights still reflect my memories in the art. A group of soldiers on the road ahead in the rain, with no way to tell who they were. A village sending someone out with a desperate plea for a doctor. Marauders dropping mortar shells on a settlement that refused to pay protection. Hearing a fight somewhere off the road and deciding whether to scout it. Riding shotgun on a horse-and-wagon convoy of food heading to a town to fill winter stocks, with Hummers rolling alongside, machine guns out. The rumor mill in a market goes wild for a week, then turns out to be nothing. Black-powder muzzle loaders for sale next to the vegetables while the local militia walked past. Strongmen acting like kings, complete with their own little courts. Freedom fighters and political parties still active; this is Europe, after all. A school with actual students. Murmurs of a new war.

The art is what keeps pulling me back. It is cold, tired, and still human. Free League’s production has always been the best in the hobby, and this line still looks like a game I want to open. The core set is small enough that thinking about it does not require clearing another shelf. Expansions can stay to the side until the base loop is actually used. Solo rules and the sandbox are already in the box. A single encounter can carry a night.

I hope the new expansion gets here before the world ends (again).

The game is a classic. The setting still feels like the one we played when the first edition came out. The box is out again because the art is inspiring and because I am thinking about it. That is enough for now. Solo play is the icing on the cake.

No game yet. Just the box on the table and memories.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

The Unhinged Champions Game

Ever have one of those game sessions that completely changes how you see a game? Well, I had one recently, with the Champions/Hero System. Now, in hindsight, this could have happened just as easily with GURPS. But GURPS feels like it comes with built-in genre-toolkit limitations and toggles, since the system has generous toolkit support, plenty of books that toggle certain things on or off, and cinematic combat rules.

Champions has suggestions, but no rules enforcing tone or realism. We get this in the Hero System 6th Edition rules:

"Some modern comic books, which attempt to portray the “actual” effects of superpowers (i.e., people being mutilated, killed and warped by superpowered attacks), show this sort of high level of “realism.” Dark Champions campaigns often thrive on it. This approach may appeal to GMs and players who like to emphasize the tactical elements of game combat, or who enjoy stories dealing with the ramifications of their characters’ actions." - Hero System 6th Edition, Volume 2, page 269.

There is an assumption of four-color heroism; the art all seems to fall in line with the theme, and everything feels like it is a "bam pow!" level of Batman TV show violence with superheroes swinging punches and using powers, guards and thugs getting "knocked over", and the violence level generally fitting with the art and feeling of the game.

And the above paragraph explicitly allows unhinged superhero games in the "Dark Champions" genre. There are suggestions for lighthearted and romantic games "because the campaign allows for it," but nowhere in the rules are limits like "this or that must happen because of the tone" present. Where GURPS has toggles and cinematic combat rules, Hero System is more old-school and leaves everything 100% up to the GM.

You can probably see where this is going.

But I will take a couple of side roads before we get there. D&D 5.5E, the game that never lets you die, puts death behind an "are you sure?" dialog box. Instant death is "a single blow with leftover damage equaling negative max hit points" - and not this; it says "single blow," so this is NOT cumulative. A character with 60 hit points only dies at zero hit points with a single 60-hit-point single-blow hit, though any hit is a death-save failure (crits are two failures).

In my unhinged Champions game, enemy thugs were getting sliced in half by my anti-hero group, and limbs were flying. Fire blasts were incinerating bodies, coring out torsos, and melting skin. Arrows were going through eyes. Mental attacks were scrambling brains. Constriction attacks were maintained until limbs were severed. The bodies were everywhere, and the blood fell like rain. It was just "math damage"; there were no death saves, and only outside first aid or healing could stabilize them. No rules stopped us; the damage was done, and we interpreted the overkill results.

It is just math, and the math does not care.

Granted, yes, GURPS can get clinical like this. But GURPS feels like it has guardrails and controls on tone and violence. I can say, "That does not happen here," and it won't; the world isn't like that, and those things just don't happen. If you are using GURPS to simulate a GI JOE cartoon, the world works like it works: enemies always parachute out of shot-down planes, and nobody gets hit by a laser.

In Champions, all that happens is due to GM Fiat and group agreement, and there are no rules to control tone. It is very close to GURPS, but GURPS will give you tools where Champions leaves it 100% up to you. Both are very deadly games (GURPS, I feel, being more so), but Champions has soft guardrails based on agreement, where GURPS has toggles, rules, and tools.

In fact, that paragraph in the Hero System rules opens the doors to the unhinged style of play, and it is officially supported and recognized in the rules. This doesn't just open up realistic superpower damage versus normal targets; by extension, it opens up all sorts of unhinged styles of play, including permanent character changes. If "Doctor Mutagen" uses his mutonic ray on a hero, then that is that; that character could be changed permanently. You see this in DCC, and the door to this is open in Hero System.

There are times in D&D and other modern games where I feel I am not allowed to make a ruling that permanently changes a character without player approval. Cozy has been codified into the rules.

It is funny how modern games put safety padding around damage and death, and even death in Daggerheart will automatically grant you a cinematic "death scene" like you were in a stage play and expecting applause for your masterful thespian performance. D&D 5.5E gives you so many outs that, by the time you roll that final death save, the DM will just wave it off and have something save you at the last moment because of all the drama that has built up to that fateful moment. D&D has decreed what resting does and how it heals everything. Draw Steel (great game) tries to shape heroism and model it with rules, and the world is shaped directly by the rules.

Even the concepts of "hit points" and Palladium's SDC shape the experience with artificial health concepts. Even Hero System has "stun," but even that has a lethal-damage component.

Modern game designers seem obsessed with controlling reality and experience, even more so than older games.

Good or bad? Well, if you assume every game is about equal and handles reality the same way, you are in for a rude awakening. GURPS, Hero System, and Aftermath are probably some of my top-five simulation games, and once you've played something purely simulation, you begin to realize how game designers purposefully warp reality to shape experience.

Not good or bad, but it is a choice, and one to be aware of.

This is also something you may have a preference for.

Modern games are overly concerned with shaping heroism, tone, what can happen, resting, pacing, flow, injury, and death. They include "X card" rules that give players veto power over the game and the referee's rulings. These games have so many rules shaping tone and realism that they feel like they live in alternate universes. There is an artificiality to these games where things seem synthetic and unreal; things don't normally happen like this, but in these games, they work a certain way.

These games aren't math; they are an "experience." The experience works a specific way.

You get into a synthetic, artificial-food metaphor here, where you ask yourself, "Am I a hero, or is the game forcing me to be one?" Is this longsword lethal because of the math and rules, or are the rules getting in the way? Is there designer interference in reality? Should a long rest completely heal a shotgun blast to the face, and does a 10-minute break heal getting shot by a handgun?

When do game rules inject a false reality into the experience, and do we even notice, or do we assume that's how things normally work?

My unhinged Champions game, where my anti-heroes were unhinged and slicing through a team of enemy guards and soldiers, woke me up. How much do I like rules artificially shaping the experience? When do "reality control rules" interfere and override my GM rulings?

It is a question that never came into sharp focus until last night.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Dragonbane as a Post-OSE Game

I pulled Dragonbane down to the living-room shelf again. Last time it stayed upstairs because 5E made another promise it couldn’t keep, and that may have been my fault, but eight shelves of books for one game overwhelmed me. What changed is the other half of the shelf question: after 5E left the room and OSE became the traditional B/X stop, I still wanted something simple that felt like a combat dungeon crawler.

OSE is the clean game. One book, short sheets, characters that do not need software. You can open a small book and start in five minutes. But the careful version of that game still asks for the 10-foot pole, the torch count, and the preference for not fighting if you can avoid it. I have seen designers recently who said, “D&D is fundamentally about combat.” Newsflash: it wasn’t always this way. Maybe since 3E, but not before that. We were still thinking our way out of fights in 2nd Edition.

B/X is an amazing game, a true classic, but a combat-avoidant game is not what every table wants once the 5E books are in storage. Some nights I still want the dungeon to be about the fights, not about the resource management and the choices that keep the fights from starting.

Dragonbane does that without adding a library. The sheet is still the whole game: six attributes, skills that include the weapons, a few heroic abilities, Willpower, and hit points equal to Constitution. Professions are just the starting package- skills, gear, one ability- then the character moves through the world on a quest. You roll under on a d20. A 1 is a Dragon, a 20 is a Demon. Boons and Banes instead of a stack of modifiers. You can push a failed roll by taking a Condition, which then makes related checks worse.

The engine is just as simple and straightforward as OSE and B/X. It gives me a traditional skill system and open-ended development. This is what I want in a game.

Combat is what makes it feel different from careful OSR. You draw a card from 1 to 10 every round. The cards stay up so everyone can see the order and sometimes swap them. You move and take one action. Parry and evade are real choices. Weapons have small features that matter. Monsters often just hit, and the Game Master rolls on a table for what happens. It is still lethal—hit points do not climb, and a Demon or a stack of Conditions can end you- but the design wants the fight to happen. The point of the game isn’t avoiding fights; the goal is to finish them.

That is the post-OSE happy place for me. Not a better OSR game or a lighter 5E. A simple, sheet-driven game that still feels like a combat dungeon crawler, without the 12-page character sheet or the “fight and you are dead” feeling. It stays in the one-book zone and the night can still be about going into the room and fighting.

The bigger shift from OSE is that advancement is skill use instead of levels. You mark the skill on a Dragon or Demon and roll to improve it at the end of the session. Still simple, different rhythm. Plus, this hits all the wonderful notes a skill system gives me. This is good stuff. My character is not locked into 14 to 20 levels of pre-planned advancement where I know the entire road ahead.

Right now it is on the living-room shelf next to the other books I am looking at again. I do not know if it stays. I know it answers the specific question that OSE left open: something simple, still a character sheet, still a dungeon, and the fights are still the star of the show.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Breaking the Habit

I play solo now. Life’s too busy to put real effort into a 5E group, and honestly I don’t want to. If it were one of the other games on this list, I might make the time, because those feel like a better deal. The default 5E package just stopped being worth the hours I actually have.

The only 5E I still open is the Tales of the Valiant PDFs, and only if I turn multiclassing off. It’s still the same family- same rolls, same slots, same class bones- but between Talents, Lineage and Heritage, and the background stuff, most of what people dip for is already covered. Dropping multiclassing just makes that the rule instead of a suggestion. I’m not sitting there building combo characters. I’m running a regular party when that’s what I feel like, without the rest of the modern 5E distractions.

Nimble and Shadowdark are the 5E Lite versions that still get used. Nimble keeps the modules and the monster books but cuts the waiting: you just roll damage (miss on a 1, explode on the max), three actions, and fights don’t stall. Shadowdark keeps the ascending AC and advantage so the dice feel familiar, then strips almost everything else down to a character on a card, low hit points, torches that burn in real time, and roll-to-cast. Both let me do a night of dungeon delving without the full head-load. They’re not what replaced the habit. They’re what’s left of the feeling once the habit is gone.

The actual replacements are different.

Draw Steel could be the 4E replacement I’ve wanted for years. It has the grid, the feeling that everyone has something interesting to do, and the early-level energy my brother and I liked. It skips the late-game HP slog and the daily-power treadmill that eventually wore out. The 2d10 tiers mean you’re not wasting turns on binary misses. It’s not trying to fix 5E. It’s just aiming at that dungeon-chess feeling without making me carry the rest of the history. The Encounters book and Codex help.

Dragonbane is the quick one. One book, official solo rules, and you can sit down and get something done in the time you have. I pulled it into the living room because it turns into fun instead of homework.

OSRIC is still the classic. The newer editions keep stacking feats, subclasses, and software on top of a core that already worked. When I want a traditional night, none of them beat it. The extra layers are just overhead for solo.

GURPS still has the best character design. The point-buy means something, the advantages and disadvantages are part of the person instead of afterthoughts, and I can build who I actually want without reverse-engineering a class. More work than Dragonbane up front, but the work is on the character, not on figuring out how the current edition’s menu fits together.

Mutant Epoch is just a lifetime of post-apoc d100 charts. You roll what you get, and the excavation loop plus the tables do the rest. For solo, it’s the opposite of holding a bunch of class engines in your head- the system hands you the situation. It’s also completely outside the fantasy conversation, which is nice when the point is leaving 5E.

Champions is Superhero Battletech. Segment combat, precise power builds, numbers that model something specific. If I want supers that feel like units with costs and capabilities, this is still the one. It doesn’t ask me to care about whatever the current superhero discourse is doing in other games. The default Champions universe is better than most current comic-book universes in Marvel and DC, and all I need to do is add in my favorites, and I have an instant "best of" superhero campaign with batteries included.

None of these need me to rejoin the 5E argument or pick a side. The online chaff and anger were part of what made 5.5E feel empty to me. These either came before it or ignored it. They get me to the table on the time I have- whether that’s a fast Dragonbane night, a Draw Steel fight, a GURPS character that actually means something, or a Mutant Epoch chart that just hands me the next problem. The Lite options stay around when I want the familiar shape without the rest. Everything else can stay in the garage or my upstairs closets if I want it where I can find it.