...the worse 5E gets.
There is an element of timing attacks, delays, spell disruption, and weapon specialization that OSRIC (1E, or AD&D) does in the base combat turn that renders most D&D 5E level 1 to 5 fighter abilities useless. The more I learned about OSRIC and its massively cleaned-up AD&D combat turn, the more Gary Gygax's genius shone through in a way that shocked me.
This is seriously good stuff. The original "advanced" game beats 5E by a mile, and my first-level fighter with a longsword specialization is making two attacks every other turn, starting with the first. So, an AD&D fighter has a permanent "action surge" every other turn?
Lethality is way down from Old School Essentials and most BX "death at zero" games. Because death happens at -10 hit points and "aid" isn't a roll, I have rarely had any outright deaths at level one. Even if my party is completely defeated, rarely, they go as low as -10, and as a game master, I can rule that the PCs are captured and ransomed, or that they need to attempt a breakout a week later from a cell.
AD&D is less deadly than BX?
What? This is not what D&D YouTube is telling me.
INT casters have a "max spells remembered" that is separate from Vancian magic slots, and they fill those slots from this "max pool," which they need to swap out and relearn from their spellbooks. Magic users are powerful, yes, but they are treated with far more respect and have more interesting learning and memorization mechanics here than "member a million spells' games. Magic users are cool and need to think ahead about the challenges they'll face.
Casting time and phased combat balanced caster power.
As I force myself to learn the system, the wisdom comes through. And future editions begin to fade. We really did have the best game back then. What 5E tried to do with special powers, 1E originally handled through structure and attack timing. We had all that before they tore it out of the turn structure and forced you to write it down as "subclass options" and powers they give as you level. They removed all the built-in options the turn structure gave us and turned them into record-keeping on the character sheets.
And a lot of new games live on assumptions and fallacies from older games, push some new designer trick, and call the old games clunky and too complicated. Design-wise, many crowdfunded games can't hold a candle to 1E. 5E breaks at high level; 1E doesn't, and it took us that many editions to figure out the company running D&D ships broken editions every time they bump up the version number.
1E doesn't break, and if you learn the system, it offers greater tactical options and a deeper caster game.
A few thousand monsters and spells, along with hundreds of subclasses, don't make a good game. It makes a worse one.

No comments:
Post a Comment